US Network Court Maintains ICANN’s Security of the New gTLD Program

Considering the new gTLD Program exposed in an opinion, The United States’ Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals had confirmed the removal of antitrust and some objections against ICANN done by a company


While in 2013 a federal district court discharged all the objections, in 2015 the Ninth Circuit confirmed that removal with all the specifics. In order to establish the new gTLD Program and the application fee at US$185,000, claimed that ICANN infringed the Sherman Act, multiple laws and trademarks. Furthermore reccomended that ICANN should assign names created in’s “alternative internet”.


The rules and proceedings leading the 2012 new gTLD Program Application Round were considered by the plaintiff the result of an illegal intrigue between the board members,  ICANN, domain names industry fellows, and the mentioned U.S antitrust law (mainly Section 1 of the Sherman Act).


John Jeffrey, ICANN’s General Counsel and Secretary affirmed that they are excited with the Ninth Circuit decision of removing the requests against ICANN in this situation. Based on an international, wide, reachable and multistakeholder process, that pursues the complete policy evolution process taking to consensus-based policy suggestions, were designed the rules and proceedings that lead the new gTLD Program. Thereupon, the Court determined it could not conclude an anticompetitive accord just by the facts showed in the case.


The court decided that ICANN is not a rival in the three important markets the claimant named as the foundation of its objection (quoting the tests from Section 2 of the Sherman Act):
1. The market to operate as a TLD registry;
2. The global market for domain names;
3. The market for blocking or protective registration services.


As a conclusion, the Court determined that trademark objections were not founded and its common law objections supported facts that sustain an objection against ICANN. In this situation, ICANN was defended by Jones Day.

Latest posts from Domain News
    According to eNaming, it was recently launched the perfect premium domain name, “ ”, for companies centered on e
    What Canon Does? Considered the 10th largest public company in Japan, Canon is a Japanese multinational corporation profiled in th
  • premiumdns
    Namecheap, one of the top domain registrars and web hosting providers worldwide, has come up with a solution to protect its custom
  • DNSeattle Meetup
    Last week it took place an important meeting at GoDaddy’s office in Seattle, Washington. Without further introductions I can tel
  • .insurance domains
    On May 31st, 2012 ftLD Registry Services LLC applied for the .insurance and .bank TLDs. According to their head of operations, Cra
  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *